
Schumer defends voting with GOP saying shutdown is worse
Clip: 3/19/2025 | 13m 13sVideo has Closed Captions
'We had an awful choice': Schumer defends voting with GOP saying shutdown would be worse
Democrats have few options for challenging President Trump and GOP majorities in Congress. Some on the left say they had a chance last week, but top Democratic Sen. Chuck Schumer voted with the GOP and supplied the needed votes to pass a funding bill, angering many in his party. Geoff Bennett spoke with Schumer about that criticism and his new book, “Antisemitism in America: A Warning."
Major corporate funding for the PBS News Hour is provided by BDO, BNSF, Consumer Cellular, American Cruise Lines, and Raymond James. Funding for the PBS NewsHour Weekend is provided by...

Schumer defends voting with GOP saying shutdown is worse
Clip: 3/19/2025 | 13m 13sVideo has Closed Captions
Democrats have few options for challenging President Trump and GOP majorities in Congress. Some on the left say they had a chance last week, but top Democratic Sen. Chuck Schumer voted with the GOP and supplied the needed votes to pass a funding bill, angering many in his party. Geoff Bennett spoke with Schumer about that criticism and his new book, “Antisemitism in America: A Warning."
How to Watch PBS News Hour
PBS News Hour is available to stream on pbs.org and the free PBS App, available on iPhone, Apple TV, Android TV, Android smartphones, Amazon Fire TV, Amazon Fire Tablet, Roku, Samsung Smart TV, and Vizio.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipGEOFF BENNETT: Democrats have few# options for challenging President## Trump and the GOP majorities in the# House and Senate.
But some on the## left say they had a chance to do just that# last week, when Senate Republicans needed## votes from their Democratic colleagues# to pass the government funding bill.
The top Democrat, Senator Chuck Schumer, however,## voted with the GOP and supplied the# needed votes, angering many in his party.
SEN. PATTY MURRAY (D-WA): Let me be# clear.
In my time in Congress, never,## ever has one party written partisan,# full-year appropriations bills for all## of government and expected the other# party to go along without any input.
GOV.
JOSH SHAPIRO (D-PA): I would have liked to# see when Chuck Schumer had leverage here to say,## we need A, B, C and D for the Democratic Party# and force the Republicans to meet him halfway.
REP. ALEXANDRIA OCASIO-CORTEZ (D-NY):# To see Senate Democrats even consider## acquiescing to Elon Musk, I think# it is a huge slap in the face and## I think that there's a wide sense of betrayal# if things proceed as currently planned.
REP. NANCY PELOSI (D-CA): I myself don't give away## anything for nothing.
And I think# that's what happened the other day.
GEOFF BENNETT: We spoke with Senator# Schumer earlier today about that criticism,## Democrats' path forward and his new book,# "Antisemitism in America: A Warning."
Leader Schumer, welcome back to the "News Hour."
SEN. CHUCK SCHUMER (D-NY): Glad to be back.
GEOFF BENNETT: I want to start# with your support of the GOP## funding bill and the criticism# that you have received as a result.
I know that you maintain that a shutdown# would have been far worse than passing## the Republican bill.
What do you# see that the vast majority of Hill## Democrats don't see?
Why are they wrong# in saying that you should have blocked?
SEN. CHUCK SCHUMER: Well, Geoff, I knew# when I made my decision there'd be a lot## of people who disagreed with it, but# I felt it was imperative that I do.
The C. -- we had an awful choice, a Hobson's# choice, between a C.R.
bill, which had no## Democratic input, a continuing resolution to fund# the government, and a government shutdown.
As## bad as the C.R.
bill was, the shutdown, I'd say,# would be 15, 20 times worse, and let me explain.
In a shutdown, the whole government shuts# down, and then the executive branch solely## determines what is -- quote -- "essential"# and what is not essential.
So they could say## on day two of the shutdown, SNAP, food# for kids, not essential.
On day four,## no transit funds, mass transit or other,# are essential.
We will only declare as## essential in the transportation# bill air traffic controllers.
On day six, Medicaid, half of it not essential.# We can cut Medicaid, cut rural hospitals,## cut community health centers.
And who has# the power to do this?
The executive.
The## courts have ruled that they have no say, that# the executive makes the sole determination.
Now, in the old days with a shutdown, they# might do little things around the edges,## but look who's in charge now, Musk,# DOGE, and probably worst of all this man,## Vought -- you spell his name, V-O-U-G-H-T --# he's in charge of OMB, which determines the## shutdown.
They want to slash the federal# government.
They want to cut it in half,## all so they can give tax breaks# to their billionaire friends.
And making it even worse, there's# no exit strategy.
In other words,## how long do you stay in the shutdown?
It's# totally up to those evil people who hate## the federal government, who hate all the# good things that we have been able to do.
One of the Republican senators told the Democratic# Senator, if you go to shutdown, we will be in it## for six, nine months until we destroy the federal# government.
So, while certainly the C.R.
was bad,## when you just had those two choices, in# my view, the shutdown had to be avoided.
GEOFF BENNETT: But when you hear the governor# of Pennsylvania say that you squandered your## leverage, or Speaker Emerita# Nancy Pelosi saying that you## gave up the votes and got nothing# in return, how does that strike you?
There are Democrats who say that, if the# government had shut down, you force Republicans## to own it.
All the pain that Americans would feel# that you just described, Republicans would pay the## political price.
Why not be as tactically ruthless# as Republicans have shown themselves to be?
SEN. CHUCK SCHUMER: Well, first, there was no# choice.
The Republicans had given us, when they## sent it over from the House, just two choices.# C.R.
as is or shutdown.
There was no other choice.
But, second, if you think that these# Republicans would come to us and say,## oh, we shouldn't have shut down the food# stamps, we shouldn't have shut down Medicaid,## we shouldn't have slashed the federal government,## I don't think that's at all an accurate# reading of who they are and what they are.
And the danger that my prognosis is correct,# which I believe it is, was so, so great,## in terms of destruction, they could furlough# employees forever and just have the federal## government shrink to half its size en# masse.
That would have been the worst,## worst, worst alternative.
And there was# no -- no -- to rely on Republicans, oh,## we surrender, we will come to the table because# what we're doing is bad, doesn't make sense to me.
GEOFF BENNETT: Beyond the questions about# this bill, there are deeper questions,## as you well know, about the approach,# the sense among Democrats that the## Donald Trump of the second term is more# emboldened, more defiant, more divisive,## more dangerous, many Democrats believe,# than the Donald Trump of the first... and that Democrats appear divided... SEN. CHUCK SCHUMER: Geoff, I believe# that too.
I believe that too.
GEOFF BENNETT: So what's the strategy to meet the goal?
SEN. CHUCK SCHUMER: Yes.
Well, look,# OK, so we -- there were divisions,## as I said.
I knew that some --# many people would disagree with me.
I felt, Geoff, as a leader, my job, if# there was such danger, such tragedy,## such horror a little bit around# the curve, that I as leader had the## obligation to make sure that didn't happen,# even though I knew there'd be disagreement.
But, going forward, we are all united,## Hakeem and I and all of us.
And what are we# united doing?
Focusing on how bad Trump is.
GEOFF BENNETT: Channeling what I# would imagine would be some of the## pushback from the Democratic base,# it would be that naming and shaming## with Donald Trump doesn't work.
That's what# Democrats have done for the past two years.
In this last election, he#won the popular vote, the Electoral College,## every battleground state.
So# the rules of political gravity,## press conferences and bold statements# and coordinated tweets, it doesn't work.
GEOFF BENNETT: I mean, what does# the fight look like in 2025?
SEN. CHUCK SCHUMER: We're going to go after# -- we're going after him in every way.
And, by the way, the people before who said he'd# be shamed and come to the table, that's the exact## opposite of what that is.
So you can't have it# both ways.
But I would say this.
We are -- we --## in 2017, when he was last here, Nancy Pelosi and# I said we're going to go after him on health care.## He was very unpopular with that.
We're going# to go after him on tax breaks for the rich.
And then we won the House and picked up some# seats in the Senate in 2018.
Same thing is## going to happen now.
And we're going to# go after him in so many different ways.## We are doing much better on the social# media led by Cory Booker and Tina Smith## in our house.
And so we're reaching# people who were not reached before.
We are -- we are mobilizing in New# York.
We have people going to the## Republican districts and going after# -- going after these Republicans who## are voting for this and forcing them# to either face -- change their vote## or face the consequences.
This is a long,# relentless fight that we fight every day.
And I am confident that we will# bring Trump's popularity numbers## and strength down if we keep at# it and keep at it and keep at it.
GEOFF BENNETT: There are those who believe that# we are in real time living through an assault on## the constitutional order.
Do you believe that# we are in a constitutional crisis right now?
SEN. CHUCK SCHUMER: Yes, our democracy is# at risk because Donald Trump shows that## he wishes to violate the laws# in many, many different ways.
The good news here is, we did put 235 judges,# progressive judges, judges not under the control## of Trump, last year on the bench, and they are# ruling against Trump time after time after time.## And we hope that the appellate# courts, when it gets up there,## and the Supreme Court will uphold those# rulings.
They restored the money to NIH.## They required that 8,000 employees,# federal employees, have to come back.
We're in over 100 lawsuits against them,## and we are having a good deal of success.# It's only at the lower court level right now.
GEOFF BENNETT: Let's talk# about your new book out now,## "Antisemitism in America.
"# That's the title of the book.
You are the highest-ranking Jewish# elected official in America ever.
And## you write that you once felt that your# Jewish identity could be worn lightly,## but that you now feel it's your duty to alert# our country to the rising tide of antisemitism.
There are a number of audiences for this book,## but you have a particular message for# people on the political left.
What is it?
SEN. CHUCK SCHUMER: So, my book is aimed at five# groups, first, my generation, to show people, I## know you're feeling alone.
Jews tend to feel alone# in these times.
We're all united in solidarity.
Second, to their children, our children, the# children of our generation.
They're pro-Israel,## they are pro-Jewish, but they know -- don't know# the history, the struggles we have had.
Third is## aimed at non-Jews of goodwill who are friendly# with Jewish people, and they know antisemitism## around, but they tend to think, oh, it's not# that bad.
Why are they making such a fuss?
They don't carry 5,000 years of Jewish history# on their back.
Fourth is the left.
There's## always been vicious antisemitism on the right.
In# fact, I was within 30 feet of the hooligans who## invaded the Capitol on January 6.
And one of them# said: "There's the big Jew.
Let's go get him."
They wore sweatshirts that said:# "Six million was not enough."
But on the left, it's in a different way.
It is# a little more subtle, but it's equally harmful,## because when people -- legitimate# criticism of Israel, fine.
I do it.## I have -- I have gotten some people in the# Jewish community mad because I have done it.
But crossing it over, going on a subway car# and saying, all right, who's a Zionist on this## subway car?
Stand up.
We want to get you out# of the subway car, telling people that Jewish## people are vicious and nasty and horrible and# exploiters, these kinds of things have created## such huge problems for us in the past that I# just -- I warn the left, be really careful.
Don't let that anti-Israel criticism# slide into antisemitic criticism,## which it all too often does.# The final group, by the way,## I'd like to read it is the kids of America,# the younger people of America.
I'd like## every college to have this book and have# their students read it, every high school.
Do you know that 20 percent of people under# 25 believe the Holocaust was a myth?
Another## 50 percent don't even know what the Holocaust# was.
And so we need education, because that has## always been one of the greatest antidotes against# antisemitism, teaching people the actual truth.
GEOFF BENNETT: In the Oval Office days# ago, President Trump condemned you,## saying that you aren't Jewish anymore.
He called# you a Palestinian, using that word as an insult.
In the past, he has questioned why Jewish# Americans would vote for the Democratic Party,## which many people see as deeply offensive.
And yet## the White House makes claims of# alleged antisemitism on college## campuses as a way of cracking down on# universities.
How does that strike you?
SEN. CHUCK SCHUMER: It strikes me as Donald# Trump has always regarded Jews as transactional,## people he can use.
He regards them, oh, he# needs money, he needs votes.
He can use the## charge of antisemitism, even# going way beyond where it is.
And he's done lots of things that encourage other# antisemites.
He sat down with this guy Fuentes## one of the greatest antisemites in America.
When# -- in Charlottesville, when they rioted against## the Jews and wanted to harass or even burn# down a temple, he said both sides have merit.
He has allies who have this Great Replacement# Theory, which is an antisemitic theory,## which says the Jews are trying to# bring immigrants into America so## it will no longer be white.
And so# far too often Donald Trump has just## encouraged or turned the other eye# when there are antisemites around.
As for calling me a Palestinian,# don't tell my mother.
GEOFF BENNETT: The book is# "Antisemitism in America:## A Warning," its author, Senator Chuck Schumer.
Thanks again for joining# us.
We appreciate your time.
SEN. CHUCK SCHUMER: Good to be# here.
Good to be here.
Thank you.
Community attempts to heal divisions deepened by pandemic
Video has Closed Captions
Michigan community attempts to heal political divisions deepened by the pandemic (9m 14s)
Law professor analyzes Trump's clash with the judiciary
Video has Closed Captions
Constitutional law professor analyzes Trump's clash with the judiciary (6m 50s)
News Wrap: Israel launches ground operation in Gaza
Video has Closed Captions
News Wrap: Israel launches ground operation in Gaza after ending ceasefire with Hamas (4m 33s)
Social Security changes could limit access to benefits
Video has Closed Captions
Trump administration's Social Security changes could limit access to benefits for millions (6m 19s)
Trump continues attack on judge despite chief justice rebuke
Video has Closed Captions
Trump continues attack on federal judge despite rebuke from chief justice (4m 54s)
Ukraine, Russia to pause infrastructure attacks
Video has Closed Captions
Ukraine, Russia to pause attacks on energy infrastructure but still divided on peace deal (5m 49s)
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipMajor corporate funding for the PBS News Hour is provided by BDO, BNSF, Consumer Cellular, American Cruise Lines, and Raymond James. Funding for the PBS NewsHour Weekend is provided by...